Newsgroups: rec.video.satellite.dbs Date: Mon, 31 Mar 1997 20:19:09 GMT Sender: Direct Broadcast Satellite Technology From: Rich Peterson Organization: Avalon Networks Inc. Subject: US DBS Frequently Asked Questions ---------------------------------------------------------- US DBS Frequently Asked Questions Version 32. April 2, 1997 ---------------------------------------------------------- Richard R. Peterson, President The DBS Connection 1480 Lark Avenue Maplewood, MN 55109 rich@ncs.com NOTICE: This document is Copyright (C) 1997, Richard R. Peterson. All rights reserved. Permission is granted to duplicate this document if and only if the following three conditions are met: 1. This document cannot be modified in any way. 2. This document cannot be sold for profit nor included as a part of any publication sold for profit. 3. This notice must be included. Any other use requires the written consent of the author. DISCLAIMER: The author makes no guarantee as to the accuracy of any information provided in this document and is not responsible for any consequences of its use. ----------------------------------------------------------- What is DBS? Several new television services have recently become available to viewers in the United States allowing households to receive television programming directly from satellites on small (18 inch to 3 foot diameter) satellite dishes which are not movable but instead are aimed at one position in the sky. The signals are digitally compressed, allowing several programs to be broadcast from a single satellite transponder thereby allowing up to 200 channels receivable with a dish pointed at one orbital position. Programming on the various services includes most major cable services, sports, Pay Per View (PPV) movies, audio services, and specialized "niche" programming aimed at smaller audiences. These services are often referred to as Direct To Home (DTH) services but the term Direct Broadcast Satellite (DBS) services is more generally used. There are currently DBS services available from six companies with others expected to begin in the coming months. Although they still have far fewer subscribers than the Cable TV industry, DBS services are rapidly adding subscribers and the industry has very strong growth potential. As a result, many companies are interested in getting into the DBS business. What DBS services are available today? Six companies currently offer all-digital DBS services in the U.S. with their services called Primestar, DIRECTV, USSB, DISH Network, Sky Angel, and AlphaStar. Primestar is offered by a group of Cable TV companies and operates from conventional satellites using 27-36 inch dishes. Primestar has been very successful logging over 1.75 million subscribers and capturing over 30% of the DBS market in its first two years of digital operation. DIRECTV, Inc. which is a subsidiary of Hughes Communications offers a service called DIRECTV which operates from specially designed High Powered DBS satellites receivable with 18 inch dishes. DIRECTV is considered the premier DBS service in the U.S. today. They have the most channel capacity available today and have signed up over 2.5 million subscribers since starting in 1994 capturing over half of the DBS market. The United States Satellite Broadcasting Company (USSB) has partnered with DIRECTV to deliver a complimentary 25 channel service which use the same satellites and reception systems and a merged program guide making their services appear as a single service. USSB has logged over 1.5 million subscribers to date. The DISH Network is provided by EchoStar Communications, Inc. They operate from specially designed High Power satellites receivable with 18 inch dishes. DISH started in spring of 1996 so they have a relatively small market share at this time but their service has proven to be very popular adding subscribers at a rate comparable to the other services. Their success is primarily because they have entered the market with very inexpensive hardware and programming which has proven to be very popular with price- sensitive subscribers and which has caused other providers to lower hardware and programming prices. Dominion has partnered with EchoStar to deliver a 6 to 10 channel Christian religious service called SkyAngel which uses a merged program guide making their services appear as a single service. It is too early to tell how successful Sky Angel will be but it is clearly targeted toward a niche not served by the other services. Tee-Comm electronics offers a service called AlphaStar which uses a 36 dish and operates from conventional satellites. Their service started in mid 1996 and has added subscribers at a very slow rate giving them far less subscribers than the other services. They say their service is the only one available to U.S. residents of Alaska and Hawaii and it appears to be most popular outside the continental U.S. Because some services share a common reception system and operate from the same orbital location, viewers may want to think of the four possible DBS services as 1) PrimeStar, 2) DIRECTV/USSB, 3) EchoStar/Sky Angel, and 4) AlphaStar. What equipment is needed? Each service requires reception hardware that includes a dish, a decoder, and a remote control. A single decoder can decode a single channel which can then be routed to several TV sets and VCRs throughout a household. A separate decoder is needed for each TV or VCR that subscribers want to be able to view a different channel on simultaneously. Therefore to watch two different satellite channels simultaneously or to tape one channel while watching another a household must have two decoders. Some of the low-end DBS systems contain a dish which only allows a single decoder to be connected to it while others allow one or two. More than two decoders can usually be connected as well, but that usually requires additional hardware. The DIRECTV/USSB service and the EchoStar/Sky Angel service use systems that allow subscribers to self-install their equipment, although many choose professional installation. PrimeStar and AlphaStar require professional installation. Why is a decoder necessary? DBS is now a viable alternative to cable TV for one important reason: recent advances in real-time digital video compression technology allow a very large number of channels to be carried on the same frequency range where only a few could in the past. Each of the DBS services uses a recently developed real-time lossy compression system which allows an average of about six channels to be broadcast from a single satellite transponder where only one channel was possible before. This results in the DBS services ability to broadcast up to 200 channels from a single orbital location in the sky. Without digital compression only 32 channels would be allowed making the DBS services much less desirable. The actual number of channels broadcast by each service varies considerably. What determines the number of channels on each service? The various services use different numbers of satellite transponders. Further, the number of channels which can be compressed onto a single transponder depends on a lot of things such as desired image quality (i.e. resolution), frame rate of the source material, amount of movement in the source material, degree of allowable visible artifacts, and other factors. Programming containing frames with many fast-moving small objects such as a basketball game can be compressed perhaps 3 or 4 to a transponder before significant digital artifacts appear. Programming containing mostly large still images can be compressed at a higher rate, perhaps 5 or 6 to 1 transponder. Movies are filmed at 24 frames per second rather than 30 for video so they contain less source material. In addition, film is not interlaced and is in general fairly constant from frame to frame. As a result, film can be compressed more, perhaps 7 or 8 to 1 transponder for near laser disc quality. Compression technology continues to improve so these may be conservative estimates. What compression systems do the DBS services use? Each of the DBS services transmits a bitstream which contains compressed audio, compressed video, authorization information, program guide information, and other information. The decoders in subscriber s homes decode the digital bitstream converting it into video and audio which can be displayed by conventional TV sets. Each service requires a decoder designed to work with its system. Primestar uses a proprietary video compression system developed by General Instruments called DigiCipher-1. The format used by all the other services is based on the MPEG-2 compression standard but also uses some proprietary components. The EchoStar/Sky Angel and AlphaStar services use a transmission system based on the DVB standard being pushed by some companies as a world broadcast standard. DVB uses the standard MPEG-2 and also attempts to standardize more of the systems. Does this mean the decoders are interchangeable between services? No. There is absolutely no decoder standardization in the DBS world. DIRECTV and USSB use a common decoder as do EchoStar and Sky Angel. Therefore there are four possible decoder types from which potential subscribers can choose today. These four are all different and not interchangeable. While many parts of the systems are common, each of the four broadcast bitstreams contain some proprietary information which only their decoder can understand. In order to change to another service subscribers must either sell or otherwise exchange their decoders for one designed for the new service. This includes services which use DVB compliant decoders. It doesn t really make much difference what transmission system is used by the DBS providers since they all can create similar quality audio and video and none are interchangeable with other services. Can you tell me more about Primestar? A group of major Cable Multi System Operators (MSOs) have joined together to form Primestar Partners, Limited which offers a digital 90 channel Direct-To-Home service to North America called Primestar. This will soon be expanded to about 160 channels. They were the first DBS service and started with 30 analog channels several years ago. They converted to digital in 1994 and claim to be the first digital service beating DIRECTV and USSB by a few weeks. Primestar is now in over 1.75 million homes the vast majority of which are in rural areas. They have been successful primarily because they are the only service which does not require customers to buy the decoder or dish. Instead, they lease it and include the lease cost in the monthly subscription fees. They broadcast from a conventional medium power satellite called GE-2 which operates from the 85 degree west orbital position so they use about a 27 diameter dish which must be professionally installed. Primestar decoders are manufactured by General Instruments. Their reception system is called the DigiCipher 1 digital broadcasting system. Their decoders are hardware upgradable meaning hardware update modules can be attached which allow parts of the system to be updated without replacing any components. They have hinted at plans to migrate to a new MPEG-2 system called DigiCipher 2, but it is now questionable whether this conversion will ever be made. Primestar services can be purchased at Radio Shack stores nationwide. What is the DIRECTV/USSB service? The DIRECTV/USSB service is the premier DBS service available today offering up to 200 video channels. This service uses three specially designed High Power Ku-band satellites which operate from one fixed position in the sky. The first (DBS1) uses sixteen 120-watt transponders while the other two (DBS2 and DBS3) are configured to each use eight 240-watt transponders. This results in a total of 32 broadcast transponders. DIRECTV has sold five of the 120-watt transponders to USSB. (Actually USSB owns 5/16 of one of the entire satellites since federal regulations require DBS broadcasters to own their broadcast facilities.) The two competing companies both offer programming receivable with a common dish and decoder. The hardware used by DIRECTV and USSB is called Digital Satellite System or DSS(TM). Sony, Thomson Consumer Electronics (owner of the Proscan, RCA, and GE names), Hughes Network Systems, Toshiba, Matsushita (Panasonic), Uniden and possibly others now sell the DSS receiving equipment. The decoders are sold through both satellite dealers and consumer electronics retailers. DIRECTV and USSB customers must purchase their decoders. Prices range from about $300 to $600 depending on the models. Rebates and other promotions have dropped the net price of some models to under $150 when pre-paid programming subscriptions are purchased. Each manufacturer of DSS equipment differentiates their product by providing a unique user interface including their own on-line program guide with a different look and feel and different remote controls. The program guides contain programming information such as descriptions of upcoming episodes and scheduled talk-show guests. Each manufacturer also can choose whether or not to include certain features such as a Favorite Channel list or a Universal remote control. AT&T also sells DSS hardware and DIRECTV and USSB programming directly to their long-distance customers. They have invested significantly in DIRECTV. What DIRECTV and USSB programming is available? DIRECTV and USSB share the rights to all 32 broadcast frequencies at the 101 degree west orbital position. The channels carried by each service are unique and do not appear on each other s services. There is little or no free programming on either service. The combined DIRECTV/USSB programming breakdown is approximately as follows: 70 Channels of major cable services 50 Channels of subscription sports 20 Channels of special interest/niche services 50 Channels of Pay Per View (PPV) movies 10 Promotional Channels 200 Total Channels The FCC has issued USSB five of the frequencies so USSB broadcasts from five transponders on one of the 120-watt satellites giving them about 25 channels. Their service is made up primarily of Premium Movie channels including HBO and Showtime. DIRECTV has been issued 27 frequencies and programs about 175 channels of programming which can be broken down into five areas: cable programming, subscription sports, music services, Pay Per View (PPV) movies, and special interest/niche services. DIRECTV s cable programming is the basis of their service. DIRECTV offers subscriptions to most major professional and some college sporting events. They use the addressable nature of the decoders to allow reception only in certain geographic locations such as outside the local broadcast coverage areas. Significant local black-out rules apply meaning many games viewers may want to watch are not available in their area. DIRECTV offers Pay Per View (PPV) movies time-shifted on about 50 channels with many starting at intervals of at most 30 minutes. Prices for PPV movies are usually $3 when ordered through the DSS remote control and $5 when ordered over the phone. Occasionally movies and other special events are offered at a lower or higher price. The DSS system has built in copy protection technology which can control whether or not a PPV movie can be recorded. The degree to which this is used is unclear. Some viewers say a few things they have tried to record have been protected, but others say nothing they have tried to record has been protected. USSB says they have no plans to ever copy protect any of their programming, but some of their PPV events may have been protected. Customers with more than one DSS decoder in a household pay an additional fee of about $5 per decoder. Can you tell me more about the EchoStar/Sky Angel service? EchoStar and Sky Angel provide the second High Power DBS service in the U.S. EchoStar started operation in early March 1996 and has already signed up half a million subscribers thus far. They are currently offering about 100 channels from their 119 degree orbital position where they control 21 broadcast frequencies. Their High Power satellites are called EchoStar-1 and EchoStar-2. EchoStar s service, called the DISH(TM) Network, uses a DVB compliant system which sells for $200 for the basic system and $300 for a step-up when a prepaid programming subscription is purchased. Their decoder has a high-speed data port for future use. EchoStar says their system can be self-installed so they sell an installation kit as well. EchoStar leases a single transponder to Dominion Satellite from which Dominion provides eight channels of religious programming called Sky Angel. The Sky Angel service uses EchoStar s reception hardware and is complementary to EchoStar s service in the same way DIRECTV and USSB s services are today. EchoStar programming is currently priced lower than the other DBS services. EchoStar seems to be the only DBS service to offer any of the Star Trek series programming. Can you tell me more about AlphaStar? Canadian based Tee-Comm has recently launched a medium-power service they call AlphaStar to the U.S. They are broadcasting about 120 channels of video and audio services to 24-inch dishes from AT&T s Telstar 402R satellite in the 89 degree orbital position. They use a DVB compliant system like EchoStar manufactured by Tee-Comm Electronics. They hope to have up to 200 channels by sometime in 1997. A key feature of AlphaStar s service is its ability to serve Alaska, Hawaii, and Puerto Rico. They have recently announced a lineup of Spanish-language programming which should be available later in 1997. Also, they say they are the only service to carry X-rated hard core adult programming. Does the compression used by the DBS systems really work ? Yes, but the resulting quality seems to be open to debate. There are occasional digital artifacts resulting from the heavy compression used on most of the services. There is a significant trade-off each service provider needs to make regarding quality versus the number of channels available on their systems. Many customers report that the video and audio quality are excellent and the systems work extremely well. Others report noticeable digital artifacts on at least some channels. The quality seems to vary significantly across channels in part due to variances in the source material. At times the video and audio quality on all of the services is stunning. Digital TV works. What about High Definition TV? DBS is expected to be the first means in which most Americans have access to broadcast High Definition Television programming. The U.S. advanced television system is digital rather than the current analog system and terrestrial broadcasters are concerned over the investment necessary to convert to digital television. Most think DBS will prove to be the most cost-effective means of delivering High Definition Digital Television to homes in the U.S. for years to come. Most DBS decoder models contain a very high speed data port which can be directly connected to a separately purchased unit capable of decoding the U.S. High Definition television encoded broadcast stream. Whether or not the DBS companies plan to use it remains to be seen. High Definition channels are expected to occupy as much bandwidth as four to six standard definition channels, so the DBS companies will need to carefully consider the degree to which they offer High Definition channels. Significant High Definition broadcasts will likely be a few years away although a few experimental broadcasts could occur late in 1997 or in 1998 on at least some of the systems. How do I connect a DBS decoder to my home audio/video system? There are plenty of options for hooking the decoders into a home A/V system. TV sets with S-video inputs can use the S- video output jack on the decoder allowing the display of pure component (Y/C) video as it was uplinked to the satellite. This appears to be most advantageous on those channels which are broadcast using digital tape or fiber optic cable as the source. On those channels, use of the Y/C port can avoid the conversion from the digital component signal to NTSC making very high quality images possible. Viewers who choose to use the RF output to connect their TV sets do not get stereo or surround sound audio to their TV speakers. Stereo sound is available only through the direct audio output jacks from a DBS decoder. How is the DBS equipment installed? The DSS and DISH hardware were both designed to be easy to install with no professional equipment required. The dishes can be installed anywhere there is a direct line of sight to the satellite with no trees or buildings in the way. Each service currently broadcasts all its channels from one position in the sky so the dish does not need to move. The dishes typically have a built-in audible signal meter or blinking LED to indicate signal strength to help position them during installation. Homeowners can install the hardware, but professional installation is recommended. Thomson says the suggested retail price of a DSS basic installation is $200 but some installers charge lower fees. More complex installations cost more. Self-installation kits are also available for both the DSS and DISH systems for about $70. These typically contain cables, a compass, a grounding block, a telephone T connector, and all hardware necessary to mount the dish and connect it up. They also typically include a videotape which demonstrates the installation process. All the necessary cables can be purchased at Radio Shack or other similar retailers, but those who don t have easy access to supplies may want to consider the self-installation kit. PrimeStar and AlphaStar equipment must be professionally installed. What about watching the broadcast networks and local channels? Local channels are currently not carried on any DBS services so local news and other local programming must be received over the air (or perhaps via cable). A network programming package is available on most if not all services, but it can legally be received by only a fraction of the DBS customers. Network programming over the satellite is available only to those outside the terrestrial coverage areas of network affiliates as specified in the Satellite Home Viewer Act recently renewed in 1994. Those who can receive network affiliates will not be able to purchase this package and therefore must get network programming over the air (or by some other means). According to the SHVA, if you can receive the networks using a roof-top antenna you are not eligible to receive them over the satellite. You must also not have subscribed to cable for 90 days. Note that this is Congressional legislation, not an FCC regulation. The full text of the law is available on the World Wide Web at: http://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/17/119.html This may change in the future, however. EchoStar has plans to uplink local channels from several major cities and spot- beam them back for reception over their DISH system. This could make reception of local channels possible which many consider a necessity for widespread acceptance of DBS. I live in the city where there are tall buildings. Can I receive a DBS service? You must have a direct view of the satellite to get any DBS service with no trees or buildings in the way. Where in the sky are the DBS satellites positioned? The DBS satellites operate from 22,300 miles above the equator at various positions across the U.S. Dishes are pointed toward the south with the angle above the horizon dependent on the distance north of the equator. Those in the northern part of the U.S. (such as Minnesota) see the satellites about 25-35 degrees above the horizon. Those in the southern part see it higher in the sky. The DIRECTV/USSB satellites are at the 101 degree West orbital location which is above a North/South line running through western Nebraska. Viewers in the central portion of the U.S. (such as Texas or the Dakotas) see the satellite about straight to the south. On the East coast it is slightly west of south and on the West coast it is slightly east of south. The EchoStar/Sky Angel satellites are at the 119 degree orbital position. This is above a north/south line running through western Nevada. Those on the west coast will see the satellite about straight to the south. All others will see it to the southwest. Can I connect more than one TV to a single dish? The DBS dishes connect to the decoders with coaxial cable. The dish electronics have either one or two coaxial connections depending on the model so at most two decoders can be connected to one dish. It is important to purchase a package which can allow more than one decoder to connect to a dish if viewers ever want to hook up more than one decoder in a household. Channel Master and perhaps other companies sell a MultiSwitch which takes both coaxial outputs from a dual output dish and allows up to four decoders to be connected to it. Note that the base units from most manufacturers can only be connected to one decoder, so the Deluxe unit is necessary in this configuration. How do the conditional access systems work? On most systems, the DBS decoders accept a credit-card sized processor board called a SmartCard which plugs into the front and allows the decoder to receive authorized programming. The authorization stream is sent on each transponder along with the video and audio information. The SmartCard can be inexpensively and easily replaced by the owner if necessary to help curb piracy. Pirate DSS SmartCards have been developed and are being sold now, mostly in Canada. It appears the other systems have not yet been broken. DIRECTV has issued several Electronic Counter Measures (ECMs) which have temporarily shut down the pirate cards and they are also distributing smart-card replacements which are expected to make the existing pirate cards unusable. They have pushed for several indictments of pirate card manufacturers and have helped to successfully prosecute some. They say they will vigorously fight against piracy to protect their programmers, but piracy still seems to continue. What other DBS services might be available? The potential for data services is perhaps the most exciting aspect of the DBS services. Because the signals are sent as digital packets, the systems can send video, audio, and computer data in any combination to the decoders. Most if not all of the decoders contain a high-speed data port which can be connected to a computer or another external decoder. The 24 MHz bandwidth of each transponder can send an enormous amount of information (at least 23 MBits of data per second. EchoStar is the first company to take advantage of data service capabilities. They have announced a service called AgCast intended for the rural farm markets which is a circularly broadcast news service allowing display of agricultural news and information on PCs connected to a DISH decoder through the data port. The cost is about $70 for software and cabling plus about $35 per month for the service. This is expected to be the first of several data services offered on the various DBS systems. DIRECTV has partnered with MicroSoft Corp. to produce a Windows 95 based PC system which can receive DIRECTV programming in combination with data services. Hardware will be manufactured by Adaptec and perhaps others. This is expected to be available late in 1997 or early in 1998. DIRECTV says data services will be a very important part of their business in the future. What are some of the disadvantages of the DBS systems? Network affiliates provided on the DBS services cannot be received by the majority of U.S. households. For those who can receive them, it is usually not their local affiliate. Because of the broadcast frequencies used by the DBS providers, outages can occur as a result of severe thunderstorms in all DBS systems. The satellites are focused to send more power to rainier areas to help minimize this problem, but it does exist. There are occasional visible digital artifacts which some viewers find objectionable. Some claim this is very distracting while others hardly notice it. It appears to be quite subjective. Nevertheless digital artifacts are a part of the DBS services. Some cable TV customers with cable-ready VCRs and TVs are used to being able to watch one channel and record another or set their VCR to record two different cable channels while they are out. The DBS systems, like any system which requires a decoder, can only decode one channel at a time so a separate decoder must be purchased for each TV or VCR which are to be used at the same time. Also, some models don t have a program timer to use with a VCR s timer to record programs on more than one channel at a time. Many on the west coast are disappointed that programs appear very early since the services use east coast feeds for most of their programming. Although most if not all decoders contain a parental lockout feature, occasionally violent and sexually explicit programs are broadcast with no rating so they are available to all viewers who set the lockout limit at a typical setting. This makes the parental lockout ineffective. Where are the DBS uplinks located? DIRECTV uses a state-of-the-art all digital facility in Castle Rock, Colorado to uplink all programming to the DIRECTV satellite. The center includes several receiving stations and four 13-meter uplink dishes. Programming is provided to the uplink facility via satellite, over fiber optic cable, and through the use of digital tape. Equipment in DIRECTV's broadcast center includes more than 300 Sony digital Betacam video recorders, a digital routing system that includes more than 800 inputs and outputs, and 50 automated playback and recording systems. USSB uses a 20,000+ square foot all-digital uplink facility in Oakdale, Minnesota which is near Saint Paul. They are using two 9-meter Ka-band uplink dishes which are inside a specially constructed microwave-transparent atrium which shields them from exposure to the weather. EchoStar uses a $40 million all-digital uplink facility in Cheyenne, Wyoming. AlphaStar uses a $40 million all-digital uplink facility in Oxford, Connecticut which they purchased from GTE Spacenet. They use two 13-meter uplinks and one Simulsat 7-meter downlink. Can you tell me more about the DSS system? The three satellites are called DBS-1, DBS-2, and DBS-3. Each has 16 transponders powered by 120-watt traveling-wave tube amplifiers (TWTAs) suitable for both digital and analog transmissions. The satellites operate in the Broadcast Satellite Services (BSS) portion of the Ku-band spectrum (12.2-12.7 GHz) and use circular polarization. They can deliver 58 to 53 dBW radiated power over the contiguous U.S. and southern Canada. Each spacecraft weighs 3800 pounds and measures 7.1 meters across and 26 meters long with antennas and solar panels deployed. The solar panels generate 4300 watts of electrical power. The DSS system uses Quadrature Phase Shift Key (QPSK) modulation to encode digital data on the RF carriers. The audio is MPEG-1 Layer II encoded. Surround sound can be achieved by encoding the audio with Dolby Pro-Logic before MPEG encoding. The video is encoded using MPEG-2 syntax with up to CCIR 601-1 sampling rates which is capable of up to 720 x 480 images although lower resolutions are currently being used. The system uses a statistical multi-program encoder called a StatMux that dynamically varies the bit rate according to video content taking into consideration other programs multiplexed on the same transponder. Each of the DBS satellites can be configured for either sixteen 120 Watt transmissions or eight 240 Watt. This is based on the DC power generating capability of their solar panels. The DSS architecture can broadcast 40 Mbits/sec per transponder in either of two error control modes. In High mode, 30 Mbps is allocated to information and 10 Mbps to error control. In Low mode, 23 Mbps is allocated to information and 17 Mbps is allocated to error control. High mode requires about 3dB more signal power to achieve an end- to-end availability equivalent to Low mode. DBS-1 is running in Low mode while DBS-2 and DBS-3 are running in High mode. Therefore DIRECTV and USSB have 16 transponders at 240 Watts in High mode and 16 at 120 Watts in Low mode. A fourth satellite could be added to bring them all to 240 Watts, but DIRECTV says there are no plans for a fourth satellite at this time. How many of these systems have sold and how many do they expect to sell? DIRECTV and USSB claim over 2.5 million authorized decoders to date with that number climbing by thousands every day. Primestar claims about 1.75 million subscribers to date and they expect a comparable growth rate to DIRECTV and USSB. EchoStar now has nearly 0.5 million subscribers and AlphaStar has about 50,000. DIRECTV has forecasted 10 to 12 million systems sold within six years of the start of their operation (which started in 1994). USSB has said they expect to have 40 million subscribers within 10 years of the start of operation. EchoStar expects to have 3 million customers by the year 2000. Most of these seem wildly optimistic. Industry experts say they expect to see about 14 million DBS subscribers by the year 2000. The DBS companies continue to fall short of their very optimistic estimated subscriber numbers and are selling at a slower rate than anticipated. DIRECTV believes it will break even in late 1997 when they expect to have 3 million subscribers. USSB says their break-even point is closer to 1.5 million subscribers which they expect to hit in mid-1997. Will DBS hardware prices drop in the near future? DBS decoder prices have dropped drastically in the last few months mostly in response to very low prices introduced by competition from EchoStar. DISH equipment is now priced at $200 to $300 when purchased with a pre-paid programming subscription which has severely undercut other providers prices. This promotion has proven to be very popular and is rapidly expanding EchoStar s customer base. DIRECTV and USSB have now matched the prices using rebates and other promotions so a $200 or less DSS hardware system is also available with a pre-paid programming subscription. This represents a drastic drop from the $700 to $900 price of first generation decoders two years ago. Can you straighten out some of the acronyms? The term DBS should be used when referring to all of the available Direct To Home services so PrimeStar, DIRECTV, AlphaStar, EchoStar, Sky Angel, and USSB are all DBS services. DSS refers to the equipment used only by the DIRECTV/USSB service and should not be used to describe any other system. DISH refers to the equipment used only by the EchoStar/Sky Angel service. Sky is a new name the EchoStar DISH service will assume later in the year. TVRO usually refers to traditional large dish systems although technically all dishes could be considered TVRO systems. What DBS system should I get? That depends on your desired programming, your tolerance for dish size, what you can afford to spend, what orbital slots you can see from your location, and several other issues. DIRECTV and USSB have the highest channel capacity and are probably the best for subscribers who want the most possible choice and can afford a number of services. NFL football and other sports enthusiasts will also want DIRECTV as well as those who like a lot of Premium services and Pay Per View movies and events. PrimeStar requires the lowest initial investment and does not require the subscriber to be responsible for equipment repairs. Although they use a larger dish, they often have the lowest cost of entry and are very popular with rural customers. The additional 65 channels expected to be added in mid 1997 should make them more attractive. EchoStar is the low-price leader with the most inexpensive hardware and programming costs. Although they have less channel capacity than DIRECTV, they have more superstation type programming and seem to be the only source for Star Trek programming. They currently have the most transponder capacity and will likely have the highest number of available channels in the next year or two. Their Sky Angel partner will be the first choice for those looking for Christian religious programming as well. AlphaStar appears to be the choice for those outside the continental U.S. as well as those who want Spanish language or X-Rated adult programming. Each of the service providers are severely in debt and are continuing to operate at a loss. When choosing a DBS service provider, viewers should note whether or not it has enough cash to continue to operate so they are not left holding unusable hardware if a service were to cease operation. It appears AlphaStar is having some difficulty at this point, but the other providers seem as though they will be around for the foreseeable future. It is too early to tell how well Sky Angel will do, but even if it fails the DISH hardware will be usable to receive EchoStar programming. What is High Power DBS and how does it differ from DBS? Several years ago the FCC reserved a portion of broadcast spectrum and reserved several U.S. satellite orbital positions for a class of television service they called Direct Broadcast Satellite (DBS). The satellite locations are spaced nine degrees apart from others broadcasting in the same frequency range (rather than two for conventional satellites) and these satellites are allowed to broadcast at a higher power providing interference-free reception on very small satellite dishes. This is the FCC s definition of DBS and they have specifically licensed several companies to provide DBS services including DIRECTV, USSB, and EchoStar. It is also possible for companies who are not licensed DBS broadcasters to offer Direct To Home services from conventional satellites. To the consumer these Direct To Home services look identical to licensed DBS services, except that they generally require a somewhat larger dish (although still much smaller than conventional dishes) and they also require professional installation. As a result, the definition of DBS is now generally used for any Direct To Home service using small satellite dishes from a fixed satellite position but the term High Power DBS is used for FCC defined DBS services. The FCC has set aside eight orbital positions at the equator for U.S.-owned High Power DBS services of which four are to provide service over the east coast and four over the west. At each of these slots the FCC is permitting a maximum of 32 broadcast frequencies (transponders). The FCC assigns DBS frequencies to applicants in a way that gives them an equal number of orbital positions from east coast satellites and west coast satellites. The idea is that each company can provide service to the entire continental U.S. by broadcasting from both their east and west satellites. However, with today's technology, three of the four eastern positions (101 degrees west longitude, 110 degrees w, and 119 degrees w) are at longitudes which can actually provide coverage to the entire continental U.S. These are the most desirable slots and they are in very high demand by the DBS companies. Are any other DBS services planned? Communications giant MCI has partnered with Rupert Murdoch s News Corporation and together they have purchased rights for 28 transponders at the 110 degree orbital slot. They have recently announced plans to merge with EchoStar to provide a single 500 channel service called simply Sky which will operate from several orbital positions including EchoStar s current 119 degree location and 110, 61.5, and 148 degree slots. There are several regulatory hurdles to overcome, but if allowed to occur the Sky service will likely become the premier DBS service available and a very signifcant competitor to Cable TV. They plan to uplink local affiliates from several major cities and spot-beam them thereby allowing DBS viewers to receive their local affiliates in many parts of the country. Local affilate broadcast is considered by many to be the most important impediment to real competition for cable TV. It will be interesting to see how this plays out in the coming months. USSB owns the rights to 3 transponders at the 110 degree orbital slot. It appears they are preparing to launch some kind of service at that location as well. Canada, Mexico and some South American countries have been granted orbital slots which could actually service North America. At least some of them will be soon auctioning off their spectrum and it is expected some U.S. companies will be bidding on them with the intent of servicing the U.S. Cable giant TCI was not allowed to use orbital slots assigned to Canada and/or Mexico for their own high-power DBS service last year, but they likely will be permitted to participate in any planned auctions in the future. They currently own 11 transponders at 119 degrees but they were trying to get more since that would likely restrict them to a service with 100 or less channels. They have announced plans to launch satellites into the 119 location and offer some kind of service from there but details are scarce at this point. Where can I get more information? You can get more information using the following phone numbers: DIRECTV Consumer Information 1-800-DIRECTV DIRECTV Dealer Information 1-800-323-1994 USSB Consumer Hotline 1-800-BETTERTV USSB Dealer Hotline 1-800-898-USSB Sony Information 1-800-838-7669 Primestar Information 1-800-PRIMESTAR EchoStar Information 1-800-333-DISH AlphaStar Information 1-888-ALPHASTAR You can also get information at several internet sites. Where can I find the latest version of this document? This document is updated and submitted every few months to the rec.video.satellite.dbs Internet news group. It is also available on the World Wide Web from John Hodgson's DBS Home Page at and from DBS Online